Dr. Rima’s Ebola/Nanosilver Nonsense (Opinion)
The Ebola scare continues, and now nanosilver is being touted by Dr. Rima Laibow as the one and only “cure” for the dread virus.
But as I pointed out in my previous two articles on this subject, there’s no clinical proof nanosilver “cures” Ebola. In other words, in lab studies, there’s never been a single human being cured of Ebola by nanosilver.
What does exist is a published presentation from a division of the Department of Defense demonstrating that in a test tube cell culture study, hemorrhagic fever viruses like the Ebola virus couldn’t replicate inside those cells when they were pre-inoculated with nanosilver.
In my previous two articles, I explained in detail why this means it can only be extrapolated that colloidal silver *might* be helpful against Ebola, but it could not be surmised by any stretch of the imagination that colloidal silver is a “cure” for Ebola.
Now, Dr. Rima, of the Natural Solutions Foundation, has issued a video proclamation claiming that Americans are “only a plane flight away from a cataclysm,” but that her particular brand of nanosilver is the sure-fire “cure” for Ebola.
Since readers have asked for my take on the situation, here it is…
Hi, Steve Barwick here, for The Silver Edge…
I really used to like Dr. Rima. But honestly, since the so-called “Ebola crisis” has taken place, and she issued her video proclamation claiming nanosilver is the sure-fire “cure” for Ebola, I’ve lost a lot of respect for her.
She begins her sensationalistic video, titled “Urgent Message to Ebola-Stricken Nations’ Heads of State,” with the statement that “Ebola is surging across West Africa.”
That’s ridiculous, of course.
As I pointed out in my article “Ebola Mania: Round II“, the population of West Africa is 250 million people. In this most recent outbreak, they’ve had something like 1700 cases of Ebola over the course of five or six months. And about 900 deaths.
While that’s certainly tragic, it can hardly be characterized as a disease that’s “surging across West Africa.” So you have to be careful about getting mesmerized by people’s sensationalistic verbiage.
Only 57 Deaths a Year, On Average
As I’ve pointed out previously, if you take all of the Ebola deaths since the very first Ebola outbreak in 1976, there have only been an average of 57 deaths a year.
Again, that’s out of a population of 250 million people.
Consider that in comparison to the fact that here in the U.S. somewhere between 3,000 and 40,000 people per year die of the flu.
Now that’s a tragedy.
But we don’t hear anybody’s knees knocking together in abject fear over it. We don’t hear anyone saying the flu is “surging across America” and threatening the world.
Indeed, while the official CDC numbers demonstrate that a minimum of 114,000 Americans have died of the flu over the past 38 years, only 2,166 people have died of Ebola in the entire world, in that same time-span.
So I urge readers to please keep things in proper perspective, and don’t let people like Dr. Rima scare the living bejabbers out of you.
Scary Nonsense v/s the Truth
Dr. Rima then goes on to say “The fact is, we are all one plane ride away from a cataclysm.”
Really? Again, it’s just a bunch of sensationalistic nonsense.
As I pointed out in my article “Ebola Mania: Round II,” even if Ebola were to come to this country, there would still be more flu deaths each year than Ebola deaths.
It’s important to understand that in West Africa, where this Ebola virus is said to be “raging,” large swathes of the population have been absolutely devastated for decades by grinding poverty, chronic sickness, chronic ongoing warfare, famine, drought, contaminated drinking water, chemical contamination and more.
You know this is true. You’ve seen the pictures of the famine-stricken West Africans on TV, with the outline of their rib cages protruding from their skin.
So the problem isn’t Ebola. Instead, it’s the horrific living conditions the people have been enduring for years on end – conditions that make it easier for such a rare virus to infect people.
Unlike West Africa, the U.S. does not have large parts of its population decimated by constant local warfare, grinding poverty, ongoing famine and drought, contaminated drinking water etc.
We don’t drink our water out of a stream running by our village where everybody also pees or defecates into the same water each day.
Indeed, in contrast, we have modern, indoor plumbing, plenty of fresh, pure water, a phenomenal food supply, amazing health care facilities, no warfare, famine, starvation, drought, etc.
In other words, it’s the completely opposite situation here in the U.S., compared to the areas of West Africa where Ebola is said to be “raging.”
So the notion that Ebola is going to come here on a plane, start spreading through the population of the United States and wreak deadly unstoppable havoc on this country, killing every one of us unless we have nanosilver, is just plain ludicrous.
Pimping a Product
In her video, Dr. Rima goes on to say that nanosilver “Does kill every pathogen against which it has been tested, world-wide, without exception.”
Wow. “Without exception.”
Then she states that nanosilver is “unlimited in its effectiveness.”
Both statements, of course, are utter nonsense. After all, while colloidal silver has been demonstrated in numerous clinical studies to be wonderfully effective against numerous infectious microorganisms, anyone who’s used it for any significant amount of time – in any form, including nanosilver — knows that there are times it just doesn’t work.
Indeed, clinical studies going back 60 or 80 years, and all of the way forward to today, demonstrate there are a number of pathogens that are silver-resistant.
So silver is amazingly effective against many kinds of infections. But it’s not “God.” It can’t stop every infection on the face of the earth.
So why not just tell the truth? Why make such broad, sensationalistic claims that simply can’t be backed up with facts?
I’ll tell you why: Because Dr. Rima is selling. She’s not educating. She’s not informing. She’s pimping a product.
Now everybody reading this article knows my company, The Silver Edge, sells the Micro-Particle Colloidal Silver Generator, which allows you to make your own high-quality colloidal silver for about one cent per ounce, instead of paying exorbitant health food store prices of $7 to $8 an ounce.
So you can easily say, “Well, Steve, you’re pimping a product too.”
And that’s true, except for one thing…unlike Dr. Rima, I’m NOT claiming colloidal silver to be the “cure” for Ebola in order to sell my product.
And I’m not making broad, sweeping claims that colloidal silver kills “every pathogen against which it’s been tested, without exception.”
And finally, I’m not claiming that an Ebola apocalypse is “just one plane ride away” from taking place in this country.
Indeed, rather than trying to scare the jeepers creepers out of everybody in order to sell my company’s product, I candidly set forth the facts in my original article, “Colloidal Silver and the Ebola Hysteria.”
And I candidly set forth the facts again, in my follow-up article “Ebola Mania: Round II.” In those two articles, I carefully explained that the Ebola hysteria was nothing more than pure, manufactured hype designed to frighten the population of the western world into demanding a government solution to threat that, to date, is non-existent here.
And I explained that the end – should we fall for the hysteria – would be further loss of our Constitutional rights and liberties, as the federal government implements more and more new regulations to control their populations under the guise of fighting a supposed “medical emergency.”
I demonstrated through official Centers for Disease Control numbers that the Ebola “crisis” was being vastly overblown, with an average of only 57 people per year dying over a period of 38 years since Ebola was first discovered, in a population of some 250 million people in West Africa.
And I showed, by comparison, that the flu kills far more people every single year, than Ebola, and that MRSA and other antibiotic-resistant “superbug” infections kill far more people every single year than Ebola ever has in its entire history.
The DOD Nanosilver Study
And at the ends of both of those articles, I revealed the results of a clinical study conducted by researchers at a branch of the U.S. Department of Defense (DOD) on using nanosilver against hemorrhagic fever viruses like Ebola.
In fact, I posted a link to the original DOD presentation about the study (which you can see, here) – a presentation I”ve had posted to my website for several years.
And most importantly, I pointed out that this was a laboratory study on cell cultures (i.e., a test tube study) and NOT a human study.
I further explained that you can’t take this laboratory study and leap to the conclusion that colloidal silver is the “cure” for Ebola.
At most, all you can do is extrapolate from the study that since nanosilver stopped the Ebola virus (and several other hemorrhagic fever viruses) from replicating in cell cultures under laboratory conditions, it just might work, too, under real-life conditions, but that this remains to be proven.
I also pointed out that the study demonstrated several important things that have to be taken into account:
For example, the nanosilver did not work well in already-infected cells.
That’s right. The cells had to be pre-treated with nanosilver, and afterwards, when the cells were infected with the Ebola virus, the silver indeed appeared to inhibit the virus from replicating, according to the DOD presentation.
I further pointed out that, extrapolating from this test tube lab study, should Ebola actually ever come to this country and present a threat it would appear your chances against infection would be better if you were already using silver than if you started using it after coming into contact with an infected individual.
But again, that’s just speculation. There’s not yet proof that colloidal silver would work against Ebola in the human body.
Do you see the difference?
In my opinion, Dr. Rima is blowing the DOD study out of all proportion, making blanket statements for silver’s effectiveness against Ebola that just can’t be backed up with the facts.
She apparently also took a copy of the DOD presentation on nanosilver, and photoshopped her contact information into it, which has led many people to believe her Natural Solutions Foundation had something to do with the DOD-sponsored study.
But again, on my website you can view the full, original copy of the DOD presentation on nanosilver and hemorrhagic fever viruses, and you”ll see that Dr. Rima’s contact info does not appear anywhere on it.
So at this point I”ve lost a lot of respect for Dr. Rima.
As a businessman I have nothing against a person selling their product. If you’ve got something good, then sell the heck out of it, and be proud of it.
But when the sales pitch becomes so ostentatious and sensationalistic that the claims begin to border on fantasy (in my opinion), it should probably be ignored.
Now what about my company’s product? Shouldn’t I be doing the same thing Dr. Rima is doing, and jump on the Ebola hysteria bandwagon?
No. First and foremost I’m a journalist. I’ve been a journalist long before I ever became a businessman. And I’m trying to set forth the facts, journalistically, as best I see them.
And the facts at this point, in my opinion, do not warrant anybody going out of their mind with fear over Ebola. And they don’t warrant everyone stocking up on nanosilver, or any other form of colloidal silver, out of fear of Ebola.
There are plenty of good reasons to use colloidal silver as a nutritional
supplement. And if you like to use colloidal silver, that’s great. So do I. And if you like to learn more about colloidal
silver’s effectiveness against pathogens, that’s great too. So do I.
Indeed, for over 20 years now I’ve spent an inordinate amount of time doing just that, resulting in the publication of my 547-page book on colloidal silver, The Ultimate Colloidal Silver Manual.
But let’s do our best to keep the facts straight and not end up floating in the clouds with no factual foundation under our feet. Because the crash could be horrendous if we don’t.
When we cross the line from stating the facts to claiming cures that have never been proven for something like Ebola, we invite the medical bureaucrats in. And that’s when the “wrath of Khan” begins, if you get my meaning.
New York Times Takes on Dr. Rima
The New York Times has now warned that “Panic over Ebola has the makers of dietary supplements aggressively targeting Africans, claiming to have a cure for the lethal virus.”
What’s more, according to the Times:
“…both the World Health Organization and the United States Food and Drug Administration issued strong warnings about false Ebola cures.
The latter threatened American companies with penalties if they continue making such claims.”
The Times goes on to point out that:
“…an unidentified Nigerian scientist living overseas had arranged for Nigeria to get a different experimental medicine, according to Nigerian news outlets.
…They identified it as NanoSilver, a supplement offered by the Natural Solutions Foundation, which said that it contains microscopic silver particles, although, as a food supplement, it is not tested by regulatory agencies…
…NanoSilver is for sale on the foundation’s website alongside hemp oil, ear candles, chocolate and ‘mental clarity packs.'”
The Times article concludes:
“Recently, the foundation’s medical director, Dr. Rima E. Laibow, posted an ‘open letter to heads of Ebola-impacted states,’ dated July 29, claiming that NanoSilver cured Ebola.
She also claimed to have addressed 47 African health ministers at a 2007 conference and to be in touch with ‘West African governments and their advisers.’
Dr. Laibow could not be reached for comment.
On Friday afternoon, after The New York Times emailed her a series of questions, two of her websites briefly became unavailable, then reappeared with headlines saying they were ‘under attack’ and directing readers to other sites selling a different product, Silver Solution.”
A WHO spokesman went on to say that nanosilver was “an example of the type of product” being referred to by WHO assistant director general Dr. Marie-Paule Kieny, when she warned against bringing “any crazy idea that people have” over to Africa to test on Ebola victims.
While I strongly disagree with the contention that testing nanosilver is a “crazy idea” (for I believe the DOD study on nanosilver and hemorrhagic fever viruses makes it a legitimate idea for further clinical testing), I hope you can see how Dr. Rima’s exaggerated claims in her over-sensationalistic video have now placed silver in the gun sights of the medical bureaucrats, potentially destroying any chance of it ever being further tested against this dread disease.
When we start making wild, broad-based claims that simply can’t be substantiated, it’s going to bring the medical bureaucrats into the fray, whose sole job is to protect the interests of the medical monopoly.
Now please don’t misconstrue my words. I’m most definitely not against the idea of using nanosilver, or ionic silver, or any other form of colloidal silver, to help stop Ebola.
I think that idea should be looked at carefully, and tried under clinical conditions.
I also believe any Ebola victim should be able to use colloidal silver on their own accord, if they want to. I know I would were I to ever end up with an Ebola infection.
But what I am against is using rank sensationalism to manipulate people through fear.
In this age of strange diseases in which we now live, there are certainly times to be afraid. But there are also times to see through the fear being promulgated by people for nefarious purposes.
I still believe the so-called “Ebola crisis” is being promulgated by the government/news media axis for the sole purpose of getting new regulations on the books that will rob us of what few Constitutional rights we have left, under the guise of a “medical crisis.”
And because of that, I, for one, simply won’t participate in all of the fear-mongering.
I’ll add that I do agree with Mike Adams, from NaturalNews.com, who in a recent article discussing the nanosilver/FDA/Ebola/Dr. Laibow debacle has demanded“freedom of choice for Ebola victims who want to try experimental medicines from all realms” – meaning not just the pharmaceutical medications but natural substances such as nanosilver and others that might work as well.
Adams points out that while the medical bureaucrats are essentially declaring war on nanosilver by denouncing it as a “bogus cure,” they are readying their own unproven, toxic vaccines and drugs to experiment on Ebola victims.
He is correct, of course. As I stated above, the job of the medical bureaucrats is, above all other things, to protect the medical monopoly.
Sticking to the Facts
Okay, folks…you asked for it, and now you have it. That’s my opinion, based on the available science. And I’m sticking to it until bona-fide, independent clinical researchers with no axe to grind prove differently.
And I pray this indeed actually happens at some point; no one would be more happy than me to see silver be clinically proven to work against Ebola in humans.
Meanwhile, I’m sure I’ll have to take some flack over this, for not falling in line with the current Ebola hysteria and for not joining in with the “nanosilver cures Ebola” crowd.
But I’ve taken flack before for standing up for the facts as I best understand them.
Indeed, anyone who’s been reading my articles for any length of time knows I’m one of the world’s biggest proponents of the responsible usage of colloidal silver, and that I’ve advocated for, and defended colloidal silver against its many naysayers time after time after time after time.
If you’d like to read more of my articles on colloidal silver, just go to the Colloidal Silver Update page on TheSilverEdge.com website.
Meanwhile, I’ll be back next week with another insightful article on colloidal silver….
Yours for the safe, sane and responsible use of colloidal silver,
Steve Barwick, author
The Ultimate Colloidal Silver Manual
FREE Colloidal Silver Safe Dosage Report
Colloidal Silver Secrets Group on Facebook
Make Your Own Colloidal Silver for Pennies
.999 Pure Silver Wire for Making Colloidal Silver
Subscribe to the Colloidal Silver Secrets Ezine
Videos on Making and Using Colloidal Silver
Real-Life Colloidal Silver Success Stories
Colloidal Silver Update (News & Views)
The Ultimate Colloidal Silver Manual
The Colloidal Silver Secrets Video
Colloidal Silver Cures MRSA
Colloidal Silver Kills Viruses
Colloidal Silver Secrets blog
Meet Steve Barwick
Important Note and Disclaimer: The contents of this Ezine have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. Information conveyed herein is from sources deemed to be accurate and reliable, but no guarantee can be made in regards to the accuracy and reliability thereof. The author, Steve Barwick, is a natural health journalist with over 30 years of experience writing professionally about natural health topics. He is not a doctor. Therefore, nothing stated in this Ezine should be construed as prescriptive in nature, nor is any part of this Ezine meant to be considered a substitute for professional medical advice. Nothing reported herein is intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. The author is simply reporting in journalistic fashion what he has learned during the past 17 years of journalistic research into colloidal silver and its usage. Therefore, the information and data presented should be considered for informational purposes only, and approached with caution. Readers should verify for themselves, and to their own satisfaction, from other knowledgeable sources such as their doctor, the accuracy and reliability of all reports, ideas, conclusions, comments and opinions stated herein. All important health care decisions should be made under the guidance and direction of a legitimate, knowledgeable and experienced health care professional. Readers are solely responsible for their choices. The author and publisher disclaim responsibility and/or liability for any loss or hardship that may be incurred as a result of the use or application of any information included in this Ezine.
Copyright 2014 | Life & Health Research Group, LLC | PO Box 1239 | Peoria AZ 85380-1239 | All rights reserved.